Belongs To The Olfactory Notes Family Similar to Fougere d'Argent - TF
terrya5
April 06, 2023
Option Review:50ml Spray Unfortunately for it does miss the nuances of the original which make it as good as it is. The herbaceous quality is a bit too dominant and quite smokey, whilst the smooth creamy facets are left wanting. So I would ‘t say it’s a like for like fragrance. However, projection/ performance is quite good.
Hopefully PP revisit this one as it does need some tweaking
Belongs To The Olfactory Notes Family Similar to Fougere d'Argent - TF
terrya5
April 05, 2023
Option Review:50ml Spray I would say PP miss the mark on this one. Whilst it nails the back bone of the scent ; the overall experience is a mild departure from the OG. The lavender is noticeably different and you don’t get the slight citrus zip you do from the OG. Whilst there is no mint in the original you certainly get an aura of freshness which is lacking in this particular dupe and the creamy facet is replaced with something a bit stale smelling. Performance wise, very good. Projection and longevity is certainly there.
Hopefully the scent is re-visited by the folks at PP as the original is a true beauty and they’re aren’t massively far off
Belongs To The Olfactory Notes Family Similar to Tygar - Bvlgari
terrya5
May 12, 2022
Option Review:60ml Spray Extract A very simplistic, yet lovely fizzy and refreshing fragrance. Often compared to afternoon swim, a comparison I wouldn’t really associate to this frag.
It has a lovely realistic grapefruit note; paired with the ambroxan, gives it a lovely woodyness with a creamy edge. Longevity is up with there with some of my stronger scents but not as overbearing as say bergamask, scandal etc.
In a nutshell. Afternoon swim is the juicier and my preferred scent over this and Tygar is the masculine, longer lasting scent.
A pure 10/10 from PP once again :)
Belongs To The Olfactory Notes Family Similar to Elysium Pour Homme
terrya5
March 26, 2022
Option Review:50ml Spray Just an updated review. A week of maturation; or more aptly; homogenisation, has really brought this scent to life. It surprisingly matured into a closer resemblance to the extrait version of Elysium.
I own both the extract and EDP version from PP. Personally the EDP is more than good enough 🙌
Belongs To The Olfactory Notes Family Similar to Elysium Pour Homme
terrya5
March 22, 2022
Option Review:60ml Spray Extract I have seen some comments from reddit stating the PP version is note close to the OG. Personally I think this may be because this has been formulated from the extrait/parfum and not the Parfum Cologne version.
I have decants of both of those Roja Dove variants and can say with 100% certainty that this PP version is 90% in closeness to the extrait/perfum version from ROJA. It doesn’t start off as fresh as the parfum cologne but has a rich deep greeness that sits behind the bursting fruity notes; which start to dissipate after 30 minutes into a green, soft spicy scent where the fruits are still present but perfectly melded with the green, wood and spicy accords.
The parfum cologne variant holds that fruity freshness much longer but eventually gives way to the same beautiful dry down.
This is the same for both the EDP and Extract from PP. So in a nutshell;
The PP IMMORTAL is
9/10 close to Elyisum Pour Homme Parfum/Extrait
And 7/10 close to Elysium Parfum Cologne
100% worth buying and take that from a person who own originals of both version of Elysium.
Belongs To The Olfactory Notes Family Similar to Creed Aventus Batch 13ZZ01
terrya5
March 16, 2022
Option Review:60ml Spray Extract A truly beautiful reformulation which smells very close to my 2014 bottle. Much closer than their fruiter and will definitely be repurchasing! Well done PP
Silver Fern 0994
Option Review:50ml Spray
Unfortunately for it does miss the nuances of the original which make it as good as it is. The herbaceous quality is a bit too dominant and quite smokey, whilst the smooth creamy facets are left wanting. So I would ‘t say it’s a like for like fragrance. However, projection/ performance is quite good. Hopefully PP revisit this one as it does need some tweaking
Silver Fern 0994
Option Review:50ml Spray
I would say PP miss the mark on this one. Whilst it nails the back bone of the scent ; the overall experience is a mild departure from the OG. The lavender is noticeably different and you don’t get the slight citrus zip you do from the OG. Whilst there is no mint in the original you certainly get an aura of freshness which is lacking in this particular dupe and the creamy facet is replaced with something a bit stale smelling. Performance wise, very good. Projection and longevity is certainly there. Hopefully the scent is re-visited by the folks at PP as the original is a true beauty and they’re aren’t massively far off
Panthera For Men 1611
Option Review:60ml Spray Extract
A very simplistic, yet lovely fizzy and refreshing fragrance. Often compared to afternoon swim, a comparison I wouldn’t really associate to this frag. It has a lovely realistic grapefruit note; paired with the ambroxan, gives it a lovely woodyness with a creamy edge. Longevity is up with there with some of my stronger scents but not as overbearing as say bergamask, scandal etc. In a nutshell. Afternoon swim is the juicier and my preferred scent over this and Tygar is the masculine, longer lasting scent. A pure 10/10 from PP once again :)
Immortal For Men 1871
Option Review:50ml Spray
Just an updated review. A week of maturation; or more aptly; homogenisation, has really brought this scent to life. It surprisingly matured into a closer resemblance to the extrait version of Elysium. I own both the extract and EDP version from PP. Personally the EDP is more than good enough 🙌
Immortal For Men 1871
Option Review:60ml Spray Extract
I have seen some comments from reddit stating the PP version is note close to the OG. Personally I think this may be because this has been formulated from the extrait/parfum and not the Parfum Cologne version. I have decants of both of those Roja Dove variants and can say with 100% certainty that this PP version is 90% in closeness to the extrait/perfum version from ROJA. It doesn’t start off as fresh as the parfum cologne but has a rich deep greeness that sits behind the bursting fruity notes; which start to dissipate after 30 minutes into a green, soft spicy scent where the fruits are still present but perfectly melded with the green, wood and spicy accords. The parfum cologne variant holds that fruity freshness much longer but eventually gives way to the same beautiful dry down. This is the same for both the EDP and Extract from PP. So in a nutshell; The PP IMMORTAL is 9/10 close to Elyisum Pour Homme Parfum/Extrait And 7/10 close to Elysium Parfum Cologne 100% worth buying and take that from a person who own originals of both version of Elysium.
Avalanche 13ZZ01 - 0708
Option Review:60ml Spray Extract
A truly beautiful reformulation which smells very close to my 2014 bottle. Much closer than their fruiter and will definitely be repurchasing! Well done PP